The Presidio and Sherry Turkle

My trip to the Presidio started near Arguello and Pacific Street. Ramune and I biked along trails to the Andy Goldsworthy Spire, out to the Pacific coast, over to Crissy Field, and back down to where we started. Prior to this trip, most of my excursions to the Presidio were limited to running along the Bay Trail, but now that I know what is in there, I plan to make it a new favorite. This is clearly a very special place, and a San Francisco treasure.

 It was a muddy day the day we went and, unfortunately, one of the first things I noticed was a trampled banana slug. I think it comes down to bikers and hikers really being unaware of their surroundings. Hmmm…

Second think I noticed were the birds. It was a beautiful day, and the birds were literally chirping. It seemed that every time I looked up, there was some raptor circling in the sky above me. Hmmm…

My idea for a robot deals with education and observation. At first, I was uncertain that Turlke’s book has anything to do with what I was purposing. After all, she is warning us against the perils of becoming too dependent on technology. Warning us against loving things that “can never love us back,” and in doing so, replace human connection. Well, my little Bird Observer robot doesn’t carry that threat. It is simply providing delightful images for a curious public. Or does it? Will this robot eventually cause people to feel like they no longer have the need to bird watch? Will constant availability of images mean that people feel like connecting to nature in “real-time” is unnecessary? I tend to think that it does not. After all, Google Earth did not replace leisure travel or the traveler’s drive to see new places in the world. I do hesitate, though, because Turkle was once a proponent of a life filled with and driven by technology. Now, years later, she is warning us against it.

In progress

Pressing to get through the five page draft of a paper that is due tomorrow and feeling a surge from Good Day by Nappy Roots.

Heeeeyyyy....

Presidio Robot Proposal

The Presidio has one of the most diverse bird populations of any urban park in the world. While the types of birds seen in the Presidio have changed over the past 300 years, there are still over 200 different species present. The Presidio not only provides a habitat for well-established birds, such as the Red-shouldered Hawk, but it also provides a habitat for birds whose populations are threatened, such as the Western Screech Owl. In some cases, these threatened birds have disappeared from other parts of San Francisco and live only in the Presidio.

The purpose of my robot will be to photograph the moments in a bird’s life that are rarely observed by humans. The robot will be an automaton, nimble enough to reach precarious nests, and lightweight enough to prevent damage to the habitat. The robot will be unobtrusive and non-threatening to the avian wildlife. Small size and discreet design will allow the robot to quickly and easily document the natural behaviors of birds without the question of whether human presence is effecting the bird’s behavior. There is potential to capture moments never seen before; the robot will be there to document the banal moments as well as the rare moments.

In addition to photographing bird life, these robots will also collect information about population health by monitoring and cataloging the reproduction and migratory cycles of the birds in the Presidio. The data and images collected will provide biologists with valuable information, and the photographs will provide the public with delightful documentation of rare moments.

http://www.nps.gov/prsf/naturescience/presidio-birds.htm

http://www.presidiotrust.gov/documents/ptip/PTMP/chapt1.pdf

Poor quality phone shot of the bridge from the Pacific Overlook

Form Studio, week 11

Here's week 11. This is the final week before our mini group show. No matter how I feel about the final work, this class taught me plenty about the importance of making. And about following your gut. Looking back, the weeks where I struggled most were the weeks when I was trying to do what I thought Martin wanted to see. Live and learn.

Many thanks to Martin for pushing me beyond what I thought was the wall... a few times.

 

The world's first city for robots

In response to, The world's first city for robots

My initial reaction to the article in Green Futures magazine is skepticism. Building an entire city merely for the purpose of testing emerging technologies seems like a waste of resources and money. In an article in Fast Company, the author argues that, “Currently, there’s nowhere to test truly autonomous--unoccupied--vehicles in urban conditions without any urbanites around;” she goes on to say that this is “the kind of problem CITE could solve.” Huh? How can you truly test urban conditions without accounting for the unpredictability of human decisions?

Form Studio, week 10

Ok, here is week 10. I've gone minimalist.

Continuing with what I did during week 9, these are a combination of drawn lines, shadows, and objects. I am manipulating the perspective to blur the line between which shapes are drawn on paper, and which are objects coming off the plane.  

Really loving some of these. I hope I have time to do versions in graphite or charcoal before the final show.

The Uncanny Valley

Thoughts on The Uncanny Valley, by Masahiro Mori

Reading The Uncanny Valley provided context to a familiar concept. I found it interesting to read a bit further and learn about what Mori is doing now and what his thoughts are on some of the new technologies. For me, the Uncanny Valley discussion brings up a lot of questions that are not easily answered. What are the consequences when a war veteran plays ultra-real first person shooter video games? What does it mean when kids act abusively towards realistic dolls?

I agree with Mori, there is no reason to cross the valley; however, it seems like some designers and engineers are pushing hard to do so and some of their attempts are truly terrifying (see images).

Alone Together

Reflections on Alone Together, by Sherry Turkle

The idea of connection versus isolation resonates with me. In the design research class, my group is investigating what people do while they wait on the streets of San Francisco. Not surprisingly, the most common response is that people turn to their phone while waiting; they pass the minutes with texting, tweeting, facebooking, and instagramming. Initially our assumption was that this behavior is common because people want to be connected with one another. Turlke’s book, Alone Together, demands that we reevaluate our assumptions. Do social networks and SMS messages bring us closer together, or are they a substitution for an actual connection? I was not surprised to read about the college student who would rather text her roommate from the other room than knock on her door. Admittedly, I have “friends” with whom I have never spoken to on the phone; all of our communication has been through text, email, or Facebook. Even though I have known these friends for over two years, I avoid calling them up just to chat. A phone call to certain friends would be too intrusive, and maybe even too intimate.

One point Turkle brings up repeatedly is that robots represent risk free relationships. To illustrate her point Turkle introduces us to Neela, the eleven year old girl who comments that “Girls are two-faced...They can’t make up their mind.” (94) And Howard, the high school student who believes a robot would provide him with more accurate advice that his father does therefore preventing disastrous interactions with girls (51). Risk can make us vulnerable, uncomfortable, and scared, but when we take risks and succeed we build trust in ourselves and in our relationships. The idea that technology is allowing us to be increasingly risk adverse causes me to worry about my own communication patterns; however, the biggest question is, what happens when a person grows up without needing to take risks?

Form Studio, week 9

End of semester! Trying to catch up on the blog before winter break, here is a belated photo from week 9. This week I continued looking at lines. How they converge. How they behave unexpectedly. I had been wanting to work with wire for a while, and finally brought it back this week (far left column), I am excited about the result. I used drawn line and wire in the far left images -- trying to blur the lines between 3D object (wire) and 2D mark (pen and shadow).

Form Studio, week 8

A late post for week 8. Still looking at the relationships of lines and space...feeling a bit frustrated...had a less than great critique this week.

A  r  g  h.